The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently released a report titled CMS's Special Focus Facility Methodology Should Better Target the Most Poorly Performing Homes, Which Tended to be Chain Affiliated and For-Profit (Report).
As part of the Report, the GAO assessed the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' (CMS) Special Focus Facility (SFF) Program methodology, applied it on a nationwide basis (using statistical scoring thresholds), and adopted several refinements to the methodology. Using this approach, the GAO determined:
- The number of most poorly performing nursing homes nationwide;
- How their performance compared to that of homes identified using the SFF methodology; and
- The characteristics of such homes.
The GAO found that 580 (or 4 percent) of the estimated 16,000 nursing
homes could be considered the most poorly performing. A number that is approximately 4 times the 136 nursing homes that receive enhanced scrutiny under the SFF Program.
CMS uses the SFF methodology to score nursing homes and identify the 15 poorest performing homes in each state as candidates for the SFF Program. From the list of candidates, state officials select (with CMS concurrence) nursing homes they think should participate in the SFF Program. However, the SFF Program is limited to 136 nursing homes at any point in time because of resource constraints.
In the Report, the GAO also reveals that the nursing homes selected for the SFF Program are not necessarily the most poorly performing homes in the nation but rather are among the poorest performers in each state. In fact, the GAO reports that the 580 nursing homes had more deficiencies at the potential for more than minimal harm level or higher and more revisits on average than the 755 homes identified as SFF candidates. The GAO also reports that the most poorly performing homes tend to be
chain affiliated and for-profit and have more beds and residents.
In the Report, the GAO recommends that CMS consider an alternative approach to allocating the 136 SFFs across states, by placing more emphasis on the relative performance of home nationally rather than on a state-by-state basis.
Further, to improve the SFF methodology to identify the most poorly performing nursing homes, the GAO recommends that CMS:
- Consider using a common set of numeric points for identifying poorly performing nursing homes by determining the effect of adopting those associated with the Five-Star System for the SFF methodology;
- Assign points to G-level deficiencies in substandard quality of care (SQC) areas equivalent to those assigned to H- and I-level deficiencies in SQC areas; and
- Account for a nursing home's full compliance history regardless of technical status changes.
Finally, to ensure consistency with the SFF methodology, the GAO recommends that CMS consider making 2 of the above modifications (i.e., SQC and full compliance history changes) to its Five-Star System.
According to the GAO, CMS generally agreed in principle with the GAO's recommendations and said that it would evaluate the effects of adopting them.
Subscribe to Medicare Update, follow me on Twitter
@MedicareUpdate, and become a fan on
Facebook.